Savory Butter Chicken Grilled Cheese

There's something magical about opening your fridge on a random Tuesday and realizing you have leftover butter chicken that's been quietly waiting for reinvention. I was staring at the container, thinking about reheating it the usual way, when I caught sight of my sourdough bread and a block of sharp cheddar, and suddenly the idea just clicked: what if I turned this into something that didn't exist yet? Twenty minutes later, I was biting into the most unexpectedly perfect fusion sandwich, cheese stretched in golden strings between the bread, butter chicken spices meeting melted mozzarella like old friends at a reunion.

I made this for my friend Maya on a Friday night when we were both too tired to cook but too hungry to order takeout, and watching her eyes light up on that first bite made me realize I'd accidentally invented something she'd ask for again and again. Now whenever I have butter chicken sitting around, she knows to expect a text about grilled cheese plans.

Ingredients

• Cooked butter chicken with sauce (1 cup, chopped or shredded): The star that makes this fusion work—use leftovers if you have them, or pick up some from a good Indian takeout spot, because the sauce is what brings all the magic.
• Fresh cilantro (2 tablespoons, chopped, optional): A bright note that lifts the richness without making it feel heavy, though honestly I skip it sometimes and it's still incredible.
• Sturdy white or sourdough bread (4 slices): The bread matters more than you'd think; soft bread turns into mush, but something with structure holds all the melted cheese and spiced chicken like it's meant to.
• Shredded mozzarella cheese (1 cup): The stretchy, gooey foundation that melts silky and cradles the butter chicken beautifully.
• Sharp cheddar cheese (½ cup, shredded): This adds a tangy bite that plays perfectly against the sweet and spiced butter chicken filling.
• Unsalted butter, softened (2 tablespoons): Golden crust depends on this; softened butter spreads evenly so every edge gets that beautiful toast.

Instructions

Warm the butter chicken gently:

If your butter chicken is cold from the fridge, heat it in a skillet over low heat or in the microwave just until it's warm through—overheating will dry it out and you'll lose all that silky sauce. Stir in cilantro if you're using it.

Butter the bread:

Spread soft butter on one side of each slice; this is your ticket to that golden, crispy exterior that makes everything better.

Build the base:

Lay two bread slices buttered side down on your work surface, then divide half the mozzarella and cheddar evenly between them, creating a cheese bed for everything that comes next.

Add the filling:

Spread the warm butter chicken over the cheese on each slice, then top with the remaining cheese so it forms a protective, melty layer around the filling.

Cap it off:

Place the remaining bread slices on top buttered side up, pressing gently so everything holds together without squishing the filling out the sides.

Toast to golden perfection:

Heat your nonstick skillet over medium heat, then place the sandwiches in and cook for 3 to 4 minutes per side, pressing gently with your spatula as the cheese melts so you get an even toast. You'll hear the butter sizzle, smell that toasting bread and melting cheese, and know you're close.

Rest and serve:

Let the sandwiches sit for a minute or two before slicing so the cheese sets just enough to hold together, then cut diagonal and serve while everything's still hot and melty.

Pin

What started as a random Wednesday night experiment has become the kind of thing I make when I want to prove to someone that leftovers deserve a second life, and every single time I watch someone taste it, I see that same moment of surprise I felt when I first discovered this could exist.

Playing with Cheese Combinations

The mozzarella and cheddar pairing is my go-to, but I've learned through experimentation that provolone brings a smokier depth, gouda adds a sweetness that plays beautifully with the spices, and even a thin layer of cream cheese mixed with the shredded cheese creates an extra silky texture. Each cheese tells a slightly different story with the butter chicken, so don't feel locked into one choice.

Variations That Feel Like New Recipes

One night I added thin-sliced red onions for a sharp, fresh crunch that cut through the richness, and another time I layered in jalapeño slices before grilling and the heat from the peppers created this unexpected moment of brightness. Paneer tikka works just as well as butter chicken if you're cooking for someone else, and I've even used leftover chicken tikka masala and honestly couldn't tell you which version I prefer.

What to Serve Alongside

A simple green salad with a lime dressing cuts through the richness perfectly, and cucumber raita feels like it was designed specifically to cool your palate between bites of melted, spiced sandwich. I've also served it with a quick pickled onion situation and plain yogurt on the side, because when something is this rich and creamy, you want a little brightness nearby.

• Cucumber raita is honestly the MVP side here, cooling and creamy but light.
• A crisp green salad with lemon dressing keeps your palate happy between bites.
• Skip the chips; this sandwich is indulgent enough on its own.

Pin

This sandwich is proof that some of the best meals come from looking at what you already have and asking what if, and it's become one of those recipes I make without checking because my hands just know the ratios now. Serve it hot, watch someone's face light up, and let them discover what you already know.

Recipe FAQ

→ What kind of bread works best?

Sturdy white or sourdough bread slices hold the filling well and crisp nicely during grilling.

→ Can I use other cheeses?

Absolutely. Provolone or gouda are great substitutes that add unique flavor profiles.

→ How do I reheat leftovers without drying them out?

Gently warm filling in a skillet or microwave until just heated through, preserving moisture and texture.

→ What toppings can enhance the sandwich?

Thinly sliced red onions or jalapeños add a spicy or tangy kick before grilling.

→ Are there suitable alternatives to butter chicken for the filling?

Paneer tikka or chicken tikka masala leftovers work well, offering similar flavors and texture.

→ How can I achieve the best grilled texture?

Cook over medium heat, pressing gently, until the bread is golden brown and cheese fully melts inside.